Case study: Brokers logo design process
For the dacheboard, I thought it would be both interesting and useful to communicate the stages of my design process from start to finish.
I have taken the example of Brokers, a reality contest for finance college students, based in Mexico involving a stock market simulation.
The Creative Brief
When I was contacted by the makers of Brokers, it was sold to me as a very innovative and fresh take on motivating students.
I firstly discussed the project with the client in order to gain a more solid idea of which direction they wanted me to go with this. The results were along the lines of…
What product does Brokers offer?
The contest itself consists of teams of 5 members who receive a virtual portfolio of US$1 million which they use to place trades on the Mexican Stock Market and Foreign Exchange Market, with the aim of making the most virtual money. The winning team wins a scholarship and a cash prize of US$30,000.
How long have they been in business?
The contest was created four years ago and runs annually.
Principal message to be portrayed by the new logo?
A fresh, impacting brand style but still giving a professional image of the event.
Audience?
College students, Stock Brokers, Finance Product Sponsors and Banks.
Any specific images to include?
Anything related to the stock market with a modern twist.
Getting started
From this information I was able to discuss further with the client and establish my initial ideas.
I focused on possible images to portray the event and many options were considered. After several ideas, I decided to present a dollar sign incorporated into the word Brokers as the initial concept.

This inital concept was within the brief given, giving a simple, fresh portrayal of the virtual stock exchange contest. The faded dollar sign was to effect the virtualness of the money being played with. This concept was considered but rejected by the client, as they did not want the event to have the appeal of just money. They wanted to focus rather on the actual trading aspects.
I then set to work researching investment terms and tools used in the world stock exchanges. The main possibilities which I could work with for a logo were the concepts of ‘bear market’ and ‘bull market’, conveying the weak and strong trends in the trading markets. Due to the nature of the event, I felt a preference for the bull image to be incorporated into the logo, to communicate the strong competitiveness of the contest.
Inspiration
I drafted various versions of bull sketches and tried both full physique and linear options. I settled on a linear aspect.
Although not a direct inspiration, I am a huge fan of the works of Pable Picasso. In his sketch of a bull below, he manages to combine both the full physique and the simple lines. Strangely, the combination is, in my opinion what makes it work, as it is the lines which give the body a 3-D perspective.

Drafting and Development
The above work was what I kept in mind when focusing on the developmennt of the Brokers bull style logo.
The below sketches were my inital ideas. I was trying to get the image of a charging bull, again to keep the impression of strength, using overlapping lines. It was not correct at this stage and the proportions needed re-working.

I transferred my sketching to graph paper in order to aid this proportional work.

After various attempts on the graph paper, I came up with the correct proportions and found that by lifting the front of the bull, gave the correct charging posture, as opposed to head to the ground, as would be expected.
Once I had decided on this point, I re-drafted, tidied up and transferred to the Dot Grid Book with its light geometric dot matrix serving as a subtle guide for sketches.


This dot grid image was then scanned into the computer, as below, in order for me to alter and achieve the final touches using the software.

Using Adobe Illustrator, I was able to clean up the curves and add the correct details, such as sharp and curved corners on certain parts of the concept to define the parts of the body.
As the image was of an organic organism, the softer edges around the head and legs were essential, whilst the sharp corners were kept on the most aggressive elements of the bull to keep the mark dynamic
Typography
Within the brief for Brokers, they wanted the actual wording included within the logo as well as the tagline ‘Making Money’. The selection of the correct typeface therefore was paramount. If the incorrect font was chosen, it could portray the charging bull in completely the wrong way.
Serif was the typeface which was presented to the client, as I thought that the classic elegance would give the long standing competition the correct feel.
The client chose the Stone Informal typeface created by Sumner Stone fairly instantly when presented with a selection.

Delivery and feedback
After seeing the final presentations, the client commented as follows:
‘A big thank you to dache, who was able to capture the essence of our contest in a simple, elegant and striking logo. In financial companies, the bull is a widespread concept used in their logos however, Dave has successfully achieved a unique touch to our new logo without losing the message.’
It was a pleasure working with you, Sinue. Thanks very much for the testimonial and I wish you all the best with Brokers.
I’d love to know your take on the Brokers logo and hope that you have found this to be an interesting article.

37 comments on this entry so far
Amazing work dache!
Very interesting post. Thanks for sharing it.
Josiah Jost, on June 19th, 2008
Very interesting dache.
Looks great…
Eric
Eric, on June 19th, 2008
also a fan of picasso bull work
nice work here, your bull has definitely some velocity and stength. inspiring
vincent b., on June 19th, 2008
It’s great to see how other designers work, thanks for sharing the process. And by the way, the final logo looks really good!
Manuela, on June 20th, 2008
Hi everyone. I am very pleased to read your feedback. Glad you are all finding it an interesting read.
David Pache, on June 20th, 2008
Amazing! Love to see how designers are inspired.
Mel Campbell (aka ALTO), on June 21st, 2008
David,
Thanks for taking the time to post such a detailed and informative article. It has given me a lot of inspiration and I look forward to more like this in the future. Much appreciated!
Wes P, on June 22nd, 2008
Very interesting article, I love seeing the design process. The logo is highly effective, it reminds me of wonderful old cave paintings.
Lauri Johnsen, on June 23rd, 2008
Hey Mel. I have always liked your TMTI. Thanks for your comment.
Im glad to have given you something positive Wes. I am currently creating a few similar articles at the moment.
Lauri, thanks for your input. It is interesting you mention cave paintings as it may have insired me in some way. Going back to my very first lesson at art school, that is exactly what we studied in art history for weeks.
David Pache, on June 23rd, 2008
This was a fascinating read. Thanks for sharing your logo design process, David. I’m glad the clients rejected the first logo, the bull is definitely the winner here. I like how you did the industry research and came up with a concept that matches it.
inspirationbit, on June 23rd, 2008
Hi Vivien, thanks for stopping by. I am very glad to read how much you enjoyed it. There will be more like this very soon ;-)
David Pache, on June 25th, 2008
The final logo looks great David, nice to see the process
Toon, on June 29th, 2008
Hey Toon, great to have your presence on the dacheboard. Happy to hear see you enjoy the final results :^)
David Pache, on June 30th, 2008
Superb, David. No surprise. Excellent to see your sketches, and as mentioned already, I’m looking forward to seeing more!
David Airey, on July 2nd, 2008
The post’s very professional
Georges, on July 3rd, 2008
David, thanks for the kind remarks, glad you liked. There is a new case study article in the making ;^)
Georges, thanks very much!
David Pache, on July 7th, 2008
Hi David
I also think this logo is great! Nice to see the design process. Was wondering what the bull had to do with it, so your research into the stock market paid off. And good luck for the future.
Jennifer, on July 18th, 2008
Hi Jennifer,
Im glad you enjoyed seeing the process. Thanks for the comment and support!
David Pache, on July 19th, 2008
Interesting to see your process here, David. This has always been one of my favorites from you.
Kevin, on August 13th, 2008
Love it man
Tyler Townsend, on August 26th, 2008
Awesome as usual
duenididi, on August 28th, 2008
Thanks for the tips
arseno, on September 7th, 2008
This is Great. I like the logo design too though I’m not a professional. Hope to share more of your experiences.
OfficeLady, on September 24th, 2008
What an amazing post! I would like to thank you for sharing your thoughts. You are putting very good effort into the stuff you post. Keep up the good work
Cheers,
Bed and Breakfast Website Design
Restaurant website design, on October 3rd, 2008
This is an extremely helpful post, I’m actually looking to do logo redesign myself.
stock trading, on October 11th, 2008
This is Great. I like the logo design too though I’m not a professional. Hope to share more of your experiences..
saç modelleri, on October 13th, 2008
Nice post and very useful. Thanks for the indepth explanations and tips.
commercial, on October 14th, 2008
Love to see the whole design start to finish. Really helps to see how others think at times! Fabulous work!
Kathryn, on October 14th, 2008
Good work dache really creative. Keep it up.
holdem, on October 16th, 2008
Very interesting process. Thanks for sharing with us!
Mark, on October 16th, 2008
Dache, definitely a great concept!
stocks market, on October 19th, 2008
Words are insufficient to describe your work David. Keep it up!
Daniel (aka Borinagge), on October 25th, 2008
This is great, I’m very much interested on how designers get their inspiration.
Mark, on October 29th, 2008
Excellent work of art, love it! Hope to see more of your work.
Pentalift Designs, on October 30th, 2008
This is an extremely helpful post, I’m actually looking to do logo redesign ..
bigarticles, on November 2nd, 2008
Words are insufficient to describe your work David. Keep it up!
..
evhanimiyiz, on January 30th, 2009
Wow., congratulations Dache, you really did a good job of making the new logo of brokers successfully. I actually allured by the logo because it’s really striking and appealing. Good job Dache. Keep up the good work..
logoaddict, on February 12th, 2009